Friday, December 10, 2010

The Political Philosophy of Julian Assange

If you keep up with the news at all, you know that we are in the midst of the largest dump of classified information in US history. The reason why is Wikileaks and their protected network for sharing this information. I have taken a lot of interest in this issue and have been watching it closely. The questions that the released documents raise bring up the legitimacy of the established order and specifically the Obama administration. Assange went as far as to call for Hilary Clinton's resignation after it was uncovered that she ordered spying on members of the UN security council. Even as Assange faces extradition to Sweden on the farcical sexual molestation charges they've rigged up (which apparently deserved in Interpol warrant, a first in history I believe,) the Wikileaks machine is still going after having found tremendous internet support and is now supported at over 500 different web addresses.

In this paper (from Brian Leiter's blog "The Leiter Reports") Peter Ludlow from Northwestern addresses the philosophy behind Julian Assange's ideas, discovering that there is a lot more to be said than this being just an annoying bit of internet piracy. Assange's ideas deal directly with how information is shared in networks, and how that sharing forms "conspiracies." There are a ton of interesting ideas here and I highly suggest taking a look at Ludlow's well-written account.

http://leiterreports.typepad.com/files/the-philosophy-of-julian-assange-1.rtf



I firmly believe that this issue does require our political support, Assange and Wikileaks cannot fall to the parties that are actually to blame. I stand as a firm supporter for the freedom of information as a right and a necessity for a functioning "democracy," if we even want to pretend that that's what we have anymore.

-Anthony

8 comments:

  1. Anthony,

    Because you write that you are very interested in and firmly supportive of Wikileaks founder Julian Assange's activies, perhaps you could help me to understand why his organization is not merely engaged in grand theft of state secrets?

    I understand that Mr. Assange intends to justify his theft and publication of these secrets by appealing to the illuminating information which is disclosed therein. However, if to covertly remove and publish undisclosed State documents is admitted to be theft, which I suspect Mr. Assange will admit, then Mr. Assange is guilty of conspiring to steal and publish state secrets regardless of the content of what is disclosed.

    Because you describe your fervent interest in this subject as resulting from your support for "the freedom of information", I'm curious to learn how you believe that we might expect either statecraft or democratic politics to function in a society in which people entertain the 'freedom' to covertly steal and publish undisclosed documents.

    I believe that privacy is more important than transparency. It follows from this belief that the State, which is the foremost corporate institution among the nation, requires mores insured privacy than any other institution. If the state's privacy is not respected, then how can we reasonably expect our personal, familial and associational privacy to be protected?

    Sincerely,
    Ryan Haecker

    ReplyDelete
  2. "If the state's privacy is not respected, then how can we reasonably expect our personal, familial and associational privacy to be protected?"

    This sentence may rhyme and have a nice ring, but it doesn't propose any specific concerns.

    How can the privacy of citizens decrease if public official privacy decreases on matters that pertain to their job? I do not see this connection. If anything it will help us make a better informed decision when evaluating a public official to possibly vote for them.

    The real concern is with the U.S. government being unable to prevent secret information from being released to a random web publisher in Australia.

    I love Ron Paul's take on this. He's a link to a short speech he had on C-SPAN.

    http://videos.mediaite.com/embed/player/?layout=&playlist_cid=&media_type=video&content=J3QLQZ1D16HXHCW6&read_more=1&widget_type_cid=svp

    ReplyDelete
  3. Also, if you still want to check out the leaks after the DOS attack, here ya' go. There's at least 13 other redundant sites.

    http://wikileaks.ch

    ReplyDelete
  4. Ryan (Haecker),

    Firstly, even if we agree that he is stealing state secrets (which I will dispute) I do not consider this a moral wrong of some sort. Morally banning the acquisition of information that the State holds allows no room to question whether or not what the State considers to be a "secret" should actually be a secret(kinda like the State "secrets" that are the knowledge of the US's covert wars and military interventions worldwide.) To say that it is unjust to acquire repressed information from the State is to say that there are never any reasonable grounds to question whether or not the State is legitimate enough to continue to have its privileged access to this secret information. It denies the possibility of revolution, violent or peaceful, under even the worst of circumstances.

    Secondly, you seem confused about how Wikileaks actually works. Assange has done nothing whatsoever to "steal" these documents. If we take stealing to imply to intention to take from another, Assange himself has had no part. Instead, Wikileaks, which Assange founded, has made it possible for other people to leak this information autonomously. A large majority of the work done by Wikileaks is not touched by Assange himself. This is not "stolen information" (which questionably implies that information can be owned in the first place) this is leaked information, which makes the network of Wikileaks a grassroots campaign that is founded on the voluntary support of those individuals who support the cause.

    Thirdly, it bothers me that you do not seem at all concerned about the citizenry's inability to participate in matters concerning the State given that the most central matters concerning the legitimacy of the State are unknown to the citizenry itself. How can there be active participation in politics when it is unclear what actions the State actually commits? The privacy of the State that you argue in favor of has, historically, been abused to deceive the public on behalf of the State feeling that it is not necessary to justify its actions to its constituents. While there are certainly issues that should not be widely recognized and could reasonably remain "secrets" for public safety, the information that is kept classified by our government rarely meets this criteria, and instead, is kept classified as to not endanger the interests of the State itself contrary to the potential interests of the public (if they ever got a say in the matter in the first place.)

    Your conception of the "State" seems to rely on some Hobbesian notion of a social contract; you assumed the legitimacy of the entity that is the State regardless of the administration that constitutes it -- a dangerous suggestion that reeks of totalitarianism in my opinion. Before I buy that the State is a legitimate entity you'll have to show me where I signed that contract in favor of this entity, and No, I don't buy the idea of the social contract arising out of nature. The fact that you see this State as an entity fulfilling a role, whereas I see the State as only properly defined by the actions it has actually performed, is an inherent difficulty in this discussion. On my definition of the State, we cannot even conceive of the State with such an incomplete knowledge of the actions it actually performs.

    Thanks for responding Ryan.

    -Anthony

    ReplyDelete
  5. Anthony,

    I apologize for my month long absence. I will respond to some of your points as I find the time.

    The most fundamental consideration you raise is whether information can be owned as the property of an individual or a corporate body. You rightly point out that Assange's activities could only be considered theft if what is taken were the property of another. As I understand it, property is considered to be the legal recognition for the exclusive use of an item or space within the jurisdiction of the state. A simple thought like the number 12 or a triangle could not be owned because it is neither an item nor contained within space. However, a painting with a triangle could be owned because it fulfills these requirements. Additionally, a person can be said to own something if they produce it with their labor. So a melody composed by a musician can be owned in spite of the fact that it has no definite location in space or as an item. Digital information occupies this nebulous category of information produced by human labor which does not occupy a definite location in space, or as an item. The state is a corporate organization which, although not operating within another state, nonetheless possesses the exclusive right to many items and spaces, as properties for itself. The information produced through the labor of its employees and its organs therefore belongs to it, rather than the employees or the citizenry. The Citizenry are entited to many rights under the Law and the Bill of Rights. However, the involuntary siezure and distribution of state property, in the form of digital information, is not permitted in these laws and constitutional restraints. On the contrary, this is uniformly treated as theft of state property.

    I will continue in a later post.

    Sincerely,
    Ryan Haecker

    ReplyDelete
  6. Anthony: "Firstly, even if we agree that he is stealing state secrets (which I will dispute) I do not consider this a moral wrong of some sort."

    The moral wrong of the "aquisition of state secrets" follows from the moral wrong of theft in general. Theft is wrong because it transgresses upon and through the spheres of control and possession of space and objects which is customarily respected and legally recognized in property rights. This alludes to my previous mentioning of the analogy between the property rights of the state and the property rights of the individual. If a private individual such as Julian Assange, or a corporation such as Wikileaks, is allowed to trespass upon the boundaries which are customarily respected and legally recognized as property then there is little reason to expect that we might be able to insure our own belongings from forcible and malicious siezure. Or, if theft is permitted without redress when it occurs to the belongings of the state then what expectation can the individual or family have of insuring their belongings from theft. This is to my mind the most basic moral consideration of the Julian Assange case, and one for which I don't understand how Assange will have a plausible alibi.

    "Morally banning the acquisition of information that the State holds allows no room to question whether or not what the State considers to be a "secret" should actually be a secret... It denies the possibility of revolution, violent or peaceful, under even the worst of circumstances."

    Although I think the question of when resistance and revolt are permitted against the state is separable from the question of whether theft is a moral wrong, I understand that Julian Assange justifies his activities(which I think faciliate and exploit these thefts) through such a casuistic appeal to justified resistance. I didn't address this question previously because I believe that the burden lies upon Assange to describe how the governments whose secrets his accomplices have acquired are unjust and tyrannical, rather than for me to justify that they are not. In the case of Wikileaks, the sheer volume of documents relating to so many countries(hundreds maybe) appears to increase this justificatory burden to astronomically and implausible heights. Furthermore, unless Assange assumes that no documents should be kept secret by the state then he would seem to be required to describe how the acquisition and publication of each document was justified in relation to the abuses which it disclosed and the benefits which may result from this disclosure. Otherwise, the theft of each may be assumed while the benefit which results from this theft, and Assange's casuistic argument in his defense, may be safely dismissed.

    ReplyDelete
  7. "Secondly, you seem confused about how Wikileaks actually works. Assange has done nothing whatsoever to "steal" these documents. If we take stealing to imply to intention to take from another, Assange himself has had no part."

    You may be correct. I admit that I do not understand how Wikileaks works.

    "The privacy of the State that you argue in favor of has, historically, been abused to deceive the public on behalf of the State feeling that it is not necessary to justify its actions to its constituents."

    Yes certainly. I admit that I don't expect the citizenry to actively participate in the decisions of state in nation of 300 million people.

    "While there are certainly issues that should not be widely recognized and could reasonably remain "secrets" for public safety, the information that is kept classified by our government rarely meets this criteria, and instead, is kept classified as to not endanger the interests of the State itself contrary to the potential interests of the public (if they ever got a say in the matter in the first place.)"

    I agree with you that the state ought to keep some secrets from the public. The principle disagreement here appears to be the relationship of the state to the people. Whereas I had previously presented this relation in terms of mutual duty, respect, and reciprocity, you present the interests of the state and the public as separable and perhaps even oppositional. However, the state can only claim legitimacy if it adheres to the principles of justice and benevolence. The state is justified when its intrests accord with the interests of the people. If it did not adhere to these principles then it could not be considered justified in ruling over the people. Rather, the state would be a tyranny whose interests are separable and opposed to the people whom it governs. However, this would then require Assange to describe how the state is a tyranny and how his actions would mitigate or ameliorate this tyranny.

    "The fact that you see this State as an entity fulfilling a role, whereas I see the State as only properly defined by the actions it has actually performed, is an inherent difficulty in this discussion. On my definition of the State, we cannot even conceive of the State with such an incomplete knowledge of the actions it actually performs."

    Because I believe that the burden of demonstration lies upon Assange and his supporters, you must forgive me for not offerring a fuller treatment of how the state might be justified, and how the citizenry might know that the state is justified.

    I appreciate your lengthy and detailed responsed. We can duscuss this more in person later if you wish.

    Sincerely,
    Ryan Haecker

    ReplyDelete