I took a small break from posting over the holidays, but now I'm back in action!
I wanted to write about the DEA today in light of some new revelations that have come out about their global activities via some of the released Wikileaks cables. A good overview is in this article by the NYTimes: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/12/26/world/26wikidrugs.html
I have never been a fan of the DEA as a political institution. While I found the reports of their global activities terrible, I was not at all surprised to hear about the type of "work" that has been recently covered up.
The Crimes of the DEA are known. They commit criminal acts in the process of pursuing and arresting suspected drug traffickers, which often make the traffickers' criminal activity look like a bit of technologically unsophisticated child's play. They support and participate in international political corruption. And not to mention that their dealings are entirely nontransparent, leaving countless crimes unknown to the public, who provides them their over 2.5 Billion dollar yearly budget.
But this is not the Problem of the DEA, the problem goes much further than the crimes that it commits. What is the purpose of the DEA? To stop the drug trafficking? Unlikely. The DEA doesn't want to stop the drug trade (not that this would ever happen) because if it did, the DEA would no longer have a function to serve. So, is their purpose to mitigate drug trafficking? At some level it does seem to be this, but one must ask how much good "mitigation" does. Funding the continued existence of a criminal institution just so that the amount of drugs entering the USA is somewhat diminished does not seem like a worthy payoff. Plus, drug traffickers will simply begin to produce more when profitable spots in the market arise away from the DEA's gaze.
The DEA has another purpose though: To ensure that drug traffickers do not gain political power in other countries. This should be apparent as the DEA now has offices in 63 countries, and has essentially become a wing of the CIA. The ironic part about this debasing of power is that the illegality of drugs in huge markets such as the USA are the reason why drug trafficking is profitable enough to gain traffickers political sway in other nations. We are creating the problem, and also trying to fight the problem we are creating at 2.6 billion a year. The NYTimes article points out a number of instances in which the DEA worked with foreign governments to "out-corrupt" traffickers who began to gain political clout as evidence to this.
But, I see none of this as the worst problem of the DEA. The worst problem is that, short of the legalization narcotics in the USA, the DEA will never go away. The DEA has become a bureaucratic organization that will fight for its continued existence even if the goals of the institution had been achieved. The budget for the DEA has been increasing by over 100 million dollars yearly (http://www.justice.gov/dea/agency/staffing.htm) and there is no impetus for the increasing to discontinue. Considering that the actions of the DEA are covert, citizens have no mechanism to determine whether or not the DEA budget deserves to be cut. Additionally, now that the DEA has essentially become another global intelligence agency, the US government will not give up the privileged information and political power that the DEA's secret agents hold.
The DEA is here to stay and will continue to fill our prisons unless some action is taken by the voting populace...but don't get your hopes up. The DEA is another branch working for US hegemony worldwide under the guise of a seemingly moral cause. Yet, when the actual dealings of the institution are uncovered, no one can provide an answer as to how the DEA's actions are not just as morally reprehensible as the "criminals" they spend 2.6 billion a year chasing (or conspiring with) around the globe.
Sunday, January 2, 2011
Sunday, December 19, 2010
Your favorite philosophical literature!
What are your favorite works of fiction that deal with philosophical themes? And take "philosophical themes" broadly here. I have been reading more and more fiction lately and I would love to hear some of your recommendations.
Hey Hey, even the blog name is a play on Dostoyevsky's "Notes from the Underground" ...And that folks, is meta.
-Anthony
Hey Hey, even the blog name is a play on Dostoyevsky's "Notes from the Underground" ...And that folks, is meta.
-Anthony
Friday, December 17, 2010
Do People Actually Believe in Moral Objectivity? What Experimental Philosophy has to show us.
Here's an article by Joshua Knobe from Yale on whether or not people actually believe in moral objectivity: http://onthehuman.org/2010/12/objective-moral-truths/
Objectivity is one of my foremost interests in ethics. Well rather, non-objectivity is one of my foremost interests. I consider myself firmly an anti-realist regarding the existence of moral truths (meaning that I believe that there are no objectively correct moral truths. One version of this position is relativism which Knobe discusses at length, and subjectivism is another.)
One interesting facet of this article is how people's answers to the experimental questions change based on the experimental conditions. In the one case, when a person is a part of your community, a human, and capable of moral reasoning similar to their own, people are more likely to think that it is reasonable to pass an objective moral judgment in that case. When the situatuion is the same, but the person being judged is a part of another culture, people are less likely to pass an objective moral judgment. And finally, when the experimental conditions are changed entirely to the person being an alien, most people are unwilling to pass an objective moral judgment on the actions of an alien life form.
This part of the paper was very interesting to me because I have taken in interest in how it is that we distinguish between the different relevant characteristics of an actor that to determine whether or not a person can be morally judged by distinctively "human" standards.
Here's my idea: Lets say that people are ok holding other human beings to objective moral standards (leaving aside culture for now.) My question is: What are the characteristics that determine that a person can be filed under the class "human," and hence, be open to objective moral judgments by other humans? That is to say, how do we determine who is "human?" Clearly there is a biological basis, but biological similarities cannot do the entire job of telling us why certain types of moral reasoning (which deal with issues exterior to biology, like making a decision between alternatives for example) would be universally applicable to all humans. And on top of that, would biological dissimilarity exempt someone from moral judgment?
We could instead talk about similarities in human "rationality" as a number of ethicists have, but all such justifications seem to get bogged down in the moral judgments of their time and happen to file their moral preconceptions into the notion of how it is "rational" to act. (There is surely more to be said here, but I'll leave it aside for now.)
But my question is: Given human evolution (both physical and mental) how is it that one knows that the person that one is passing moral judgment on is "human" in the same way they are? Would a neurological or psychological dissimilarity between two people be enough to disqualify them as the same type of "human?" How much dissimilarity qualifies someone to no longer be considered "human?"
I am open to the possibility that humanness is a transitory state, and that the degrees to which it is being overcome through biological evolution and psychological evolution via culture cannot be objectively distinguished in the course of deciding to pass a moral judgment on someone that is to be considered objectively binding. That is to say, we have no definite basis upon which to determine others' similarity or dissimilarity to ourselves when it comes to passing moral judgments.
Regarding morals, why have we allowed ourselves to think that moral judgments apply to beings that are fundamentally similar, rather than fundamentally dissimilar from ourselves? It is only the ethicist who wants to crouch the "rationality" of morality into our specific time and place in the course of human (or transhuman) existence. The nature of morality may too be a process of the evolution of humanity.
-Anthony
Objectivity is one of my foremost interests in ethics. Well rather, non-objectivity is one of my foremost interests. I consider myself firmly an anti-realist regarding the existence of moral truths (meaning that I believe that there are no objectively correct moral truths. One version of this position is relativism which Knobe discusses at length, and subjectivism is another.)
One interesting facet of this article is how people's answers to the experimental questions change based on the experimental conditions. In the one case, when a person is a part of your community, a human, and capable of moral reasoning similar to their own, people are more likely to think that it is reasonable to pass an objective moral judgment in that case. When the situatuion is the same, but the person being judged is a part of another culture, people are less likely to pass an objective moral judgment. And finally, when the experimental conditions are changed entirely to the person being an alien, most people are unwilling to pass an objective moral judgment on the actions of an alien life form.
This part of the paper was very interesting to me because I have taken in interest in how it is that we distinguish between the different relevant characteristics of an actor that to determine whether or not a person can be morally judged by distinctively "human" standards.
Here's my idea: Lets say that people are ok holding other human beings to objective moral standards (leaving aside culture for now.) My question is: What are the characteristics that determine that a person can be filed under the class "human," and hence, be open to objective moral judgments by other humans? That is to say, how do we determine who is "human?" Clearly there is a biological basis, but biological similarities cannot do the entire job of telling us why certain types of moral reasoning (which deal with issues exterior to biology, like making a decision between alternatives for example) would be universally applicable to all humans. And on top of that, would biological dissimilarity exempt someone from moral judgment?
We could instead talk about similarities in human "rationality" as a number of ethicists have, but all such justifications seem to get bogged down in the moral judgments of their time and happen to file their moral preconceptions into the notion of how it is "rational" to act. (There is surely more to be said here, but I'll leave it aside for now.)
But my question is: Given human evolution (both physical and mental) how is it that one knows that the person that one is passing moral judgment on is "human" in the same way they are? Would a neurological or psychological dissimilarity between two people be enough to disqualify them as the same type of "human?" How much dissimilarity qualifies someone to no longer be considered "human?"
I am open to the possibility that humanness is a transitory state, and that the degrees to which it is being overcome through biological evolution and psychological evolution via culture cannot be objectively distinguished in the course of deciding to pass a moral judgment on someone that is to be considered objectively binding. That is to say, we have no definite basis upon which to determine others' similarity or dissimilarity to ourselves when it comes to passing moral judgments.
Regarding morals, why have we allowed ourselves to think that moral judgments apply to beings that are fundamentally similar, rather than fundamentally dissimilar from ourselves? It is only the ethicist who wants to crouch the "rationality" of morality into our specific time and place in the course of human (or transhuman) existence. The nature of morality may too be a process of the evolution of humanity.
-Anthony
Sunday, December 12, 2010
Robert Paul Wolff - Political Philosopher Extraordinaire
Robert Paul Wolff is a contemporary political philosopher that I have been reading a lot of recently. I find his analysis fantastic and extremely accessible. He may be best known for his critique of Rawls' A Theory of Justice where he attacks Rawls for what he sees as a faulty validation of the political status quo. He also published the popular In Defense of Anarchism: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_Defense_of_Anarchism.
His blog is fantastic resource for commentary on the current political scene. Check it out: http://robertpaulwolff.blogspot.com/
Here are the books by Wolff I have recently read or dipped into:
Understanding Rawls: A reconstruction and Critique of A Theory of Justice
Political and Social Man: Readings in Political and Social Philosophy.
The Rule of Law: Collected Essays
A Critique of Pure Tolerence with Herbert Marcuse
Understanding Marx: A Reconstruction and Critique of Capital
Great stuff! Check it out!
-Anthony
His blog is fantastic resource for commentary on the current political scene. Check it out: http://robertpaulwolff.blogspot.com/
Here are the books by Wolff I have recently read or dipped into:
Understanding Rawls: A reconstruction and Critique of A Theory of Justice
Political and Social Man: Readings in Political and Social Philosophy.
The Rule of Law: Collected Essays
A Critique of Pure Tolerence with Herbert Marcuse
Understanding Marx: A Reconstruction and Critique of Capital
Great stuff! Check it out!
-Anthony
Friday, December 10, 2010
The Political Philosophy of Julian Assange
If you keep up with the news at all, you know that we are in the midst of the largest dump of classified information in US history. The reason why is Wikileaks and their protected network for sharing this information. I have taken a lot of interest in this issue and have been watching it closely. The questions that the released documents raise bring up the legitimacy of the established order and specifically the Obama administration. Assange went as far as to call for Hilary Clinton's resignation after it was uncovered that she ordered spying on members of the UN security council. Even as Assange faces extradition to Sweden on the farcical sexual molestation charges they've rigged up (which apparently deserved in Interpol warrant, a first in history I believe,) the Wikileaks machine is still going after having found tremendous internet support and is now supported at over 500 different web addresses.
In this paper (from Brian Leiter's blog "The Leiter Reports") Peter Ludlow from Northwestern addresses the philosophy behind Julian Assange's ideas, discovering that there is a lot more to be said than this being just an annoying bit of internet piracy. Assange's ideas deal directly with how information is shared in networks, and how that sharing forms "conspiracies." There are a ton of interesting ideas here and I highly suggest taking a look at Ludlow's well-written account.
http://leiterreports.typepad.com/files/the-philosophy-of-julian-assange-1.rtf
I firmly believe that this issue does require our political support, Assange and Wikileaks cannot fall to the parties that are actually to blame. I stand as a firm supporter for the freedom of information as a right and a necessity for a functioning "democracy," if we even want to pretend that that's what we have anymore.
-Anthony
In this paper (from Brian Leiter's blog "The Leiter Reports") Peter Ludlow from Northwestern addresses the philosophy behind Julian Assange's ideas, discovering that there is a lot more to be said than this being just an annoying bit of internet piracy. Assange's ideas deal directly with how information is shared in networks, and how that sharing forms "conspiracies." There are a ton of interesting ideas here and I highly suggest taking a look at Ludlow's well-written account.
http://leiterreports.typepad.com/files/the-philosophy-of-julian-assange-1.rtf
I firmly believe that this issue does require our political support, Assange and Wikileaks cannot fall to the parties that are actually to blame. I stand as a firm supporter for the freedom of information as a right and a necessity for a functioning "democracy," if we even want to pretend that that's what we have anymore.
-Anthony
Tuesday, December 7, 2010
Nietzsche and Melville
Here's a neat article from "The Stone," which is the philosophy forum for the New York Times.
http://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/12/05/navigating-past-nihilism/
The article discusses the similarities between Nietzsche and Herman Melville on overcoming nihilism in the 19th century. The author uses Nietzsche's well known proclamation "God is dead." to exemplify the "problem" of nihilism in the 19th century, which he argues Melville provides an answer to primarily in Moby Dick. There's certainly a lot to be said for Nietzsche's solution to the problem too, which was the main question of my previous work on Nietzsche regarding "the affirmation of life" as a moral ideal in his thought. Cool article!
Thanks Amanda Lundy for the tip!
http://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/12/05/navigating-past-nihilism/
The article discusses the similarities between Nietzsche and Herman Melville on overcoming nihilism in the 19th century. The author uses Nietzsche's well known proclamation "God is dead." to exemplify the "problem" of nihilism in the 19th century, which he argues Melville provides an answer to primarily in Moby Dick. There's certainly a lot to be said for Nietzsche's solution to the problem too, which was the main question of my previous work on Nietzsche regarding "the affirmation of life" as a moral ideal in his thought. Cool article!
Thanks Amanda Lundy for the tip!
Monday, December 6, 2010
Herbert Marcuse's "One Dimensional Man"
I recently read Herbert Marcuse's "One Dimensional Man" (1964) and I found it quite enjoyable. Much of what Marcuse has to say is still applicable to our world today. Capitalism still runs amok and has heightened the stakes of alienation for all "outlying" classes (economic, racial, and intellectual,) and many "analytic" academic fields continue to add to this distance conceptually. But, given that Marcuse couldn't have possibly imagined the political situation of our world today, it is worthy to ask how American unilateralism resulting post-9/11 has changed the political game from Marcuse's Cold War world. Marcuse's analysis often points out the similarities between capitalism and totalitarian "communism" on some very important issues, primarily the social alienation resulting from the growth of advanced industrialist economy and technology. Yet, given that one system has conquered the other and shown itself superior in maintaining its forms of domination and repression, new lines of analysis need to be opened to analyze the forms of repression present in what could now be reasonably called the "hyper-industrialist" world.
There is no question as to why "One Dimensional Man" stands as one of the foundational texts of the Critical Theory movement. Marcuse's goes to great lengths to highlight the necessarily negative approach that repressed intellectual theory must proceed from, and I feel that these points in his analysis hold as much weight as ever, as we see Critical Theory alive and well in a number of State-side academic institutions.
Here are some of my favorite quotes:
"...domination - in the guise of affluence and liberty - extends to all spheres of private and public existence, integrates all authentic opposition, absorbs all alternatives. Technological rationality reveals its political character as it becomes the great vehicle of better domination, creating a truly totalitarian universe in which society and nature, mind and body are kept in a state of permanent mobilization for the defense of this universe."
"The argument from historical backwardness- according to which liberation must, under the prevailing conditions of material and intellectual immaturity, necessarily be the work of force and administration- is not only the core of Soviet Marxism, but also that of the theoreticians of "educational dictatorship" from Plato to Rousseau. It is easily ridiculed but hard to refute because it has the merit to acknowledge, without much hypocrisy, the conditions (material and intellectual) which serve to prevent genuine and intelligent self-determination."
"Under these circumstances, even the existing liberties and escapes fall in place within the organized whole. At this stage of the regimented market, is competition alleviating or intensifying the race for bigger and faster turnover and obsolescence? Are the political parties competing for pacification or for a stronger and more costly armament industry? Is the production of "affluence" promoting or delaying the satisfaction of still unfulfilled vital needs? If the first alternatives are true, the contemporary form of pluralism would strengthen the potential for the containment of qualitative change, and thus prevent rather than impel the "catastrophe" of self-determination. Democracy would appear to be the most efficient system of domination."
"Whether ritualized or not, art contains the rationality of negation. In its advanced positions, it is the Great Refusal - the protest against that which is. The modes in which man and things are made to appear, to sing, sound and speak, are modes of refuting, breaking, and recreating their factual existence. But these modes of negation pay tribute to the antagonistic society to which they are linked. Separated from the sphere of labor where society reproduces itself and its misery, the world of art which they create remains, with all its truth, a privilege and an illusion."
"Domination has its own aesthetics, and democratic domination has its democratic aesthetics. It is good that almost everyone can now have the fine arts at his fingertips, by just turning the knob on his set, or by just stepping into a drugstore. In this diffusion, however, they become cogs in a culture-machine which remakes their content."
"The real universe of ordinary language is the struggle for existence."
"To make good sense, "the nation" or "the Party" ought to be translatable into its constituents and components. The fact that its not, is a historical fact which gets in the way of linguistic and logical analysis."
"The universal comprehends in one idea the possibilities which are realized, and at the same time arrested, in reality."
"I believe that the very concept of Reason originates in a value judgment, and that the concept of truth cannot be divorced from the value of Reason."
"Technics, as a universe of instrumentalities, may increase the weakness as well as the power of man. At the present stage, he is perhaps more powerless over his own apparatus then he ever was before."
"Self-determination will be real to the extent to which the masses have been dissolved into individuals liberated from all propaganda, indoctrination, and manipulation, capable of knowing and comprehending the facts and of evaluating the alternatives. In other words, society would be rational and free to the extent to which it is organized, sustained, and reproduced by an essentially new historical Subject."
"But the struggle for the solution has outgrown the traditional forms. The totalitarian tendencies of the one-dimensional society render the traditional ways and means of protest ineffective - perhaps even dangerous because they preserve the illusion of popular sovereignty. This illusion contains some truth: "the people," previously the ferment of social change, have "moved up" to become the ferment of social cohesion. Here rather than in the redistribution of wealth and equalization of classes is the new stratification characteristic of advanced industrial society."
I'd love to hear your comments. THANKS FOR READING. Check back soon for more posts.
-Anthony
There is no question as to why "One Dimensional Man" stands as one of the foundational texts of the Critical Theory movement. Marcuse's goes to great lengths to highlight the necessarily negative approach that repressed intellectual theory must proceed from, and I feel that these points in his analysis hold as much weight as ever, as we see Critical Theory alive and well in a number of State-side academic institutions.
Here are some of my favorite quotes:
"...domination - in the guise of affluence and liberty - extends to all spheres of private and public existence, integrates all authentic opposition, absorbs all alternatives. Technological rationality reveals its political character as it becomes the great vehicle of better domination, creating a truly totalitarian universe in which society and nature, mind and body are kept in a state of permanent mobilization for the defense of this universe."
"The argument from historical backwardness- according to which liberation must, under the prevailing conditions of material and intellectual immaturity, necessarily be the work of force and administration- is not only the core of Soviet Marxism, but also that of the theoreticians of "educational dictatorship" from Plato to Rousseau. It is easily ridiculed but hard to refute because it has the merit to acknowledge, without much hypocrisy, the conditions (material and intellectual) which serve to prevent genuine and intelligent self-determination."
"Under these circumstances, even the existing liberties and escapes fall in place within the organized whole. At this stage of the regimented market, is competition alleviating or intensifying the race for bigger and faster turnover and obsolescence? Are the political parties competing for pacification or for a stronger and more costly armament industry? Is the production of "affluence" promoting or delaying the satisfaction of still unfulfilled vital needs? If the first alternatives are true, the contemporary form of pluralism would strengthen the potential for the containment of qualitative change, and thus prevent rather than impel the "catastrophe" of self-determination. Democracy would appear to be the most efficient system of domination."
"Whether ritualized or not, art contains the rationality of negation. In its advanced positions, it is the Great Refusal - the protest against that which is. The modes in which man and things are made to appear, to sing, sound and speak, are modes of refuting, breaking, and recreating their factual existence. But these modes of negation pay tribute to the antagonistic society to which they are linked. Separated from the sphere of labor where society reproduces itself and its misery, the world of art which they create remains, with all its truth, a privilege and an illusion."
"Domination has its own aesthetics, and democratic domination has its democratic aesthetics. It is good that almost everyone can now have the fine arts at his fingertips, by just turning the knob on his set, or by just stepping into a drugstore. In this diffusion, however, they become cogs in a culture-machine which remakes their content."
"The real universe of ordinary language is the struggle for existence."
"To make good sense, "the nation" or "the Party" ought to be translatable into its constituents and components. The fact that its not, is a historical fact which gets in the way of linguistic and logical analysis."
"The universal comprehends in one idea the possibilities which are realized, and at the same time arrested, in reality."
"I believe that the very concept of Reason originates in a value judgment, and that the concept of truth cannot be divorced from the value of Reason."
"Technics, as a universe of instrumentalities, may increase the weakness as well as the power of man. At the present stage, he is perhaps more powerless over his own apparatus then he ever was before."
"Self-determination will be real to the extent to which the masses have been dissolved into individuals liberated from all propaganda, indoctrination, and manipulation, capable of knowing and comprehending the facts and of evaluating the alternatives. In other words, society would be rational and free to the extent to which it is organized, sustained, and reproduced by an essentially new historical Subject."
"But the struggle for the solution has outgrown the traditional forms. The totalitarian tendencies of the one-dimensional society render the traditional ways and means of protest ineffective - perhaps even dangerous because they preserve the illusion of popular sovereignty. This illusion contains some truth: "the people," previously the ferment of social change, have "moved up" to become the ferment of social cohesion. Here rather than in the redistribution of wealth and equalization of classes is the new stratification characteristic of advanced industrial society."
I'd love to hear your comments. THANKS FOR READING. Check back soon for more posts.
-Anthony
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)